Great question - but purely subjective. Regardless of what any one else may think of these various vehicles, it all centers on what YOU are comfortable with. I have the 2012 SRX and find it to be the best option considering, fit, finish, warranty, etc. However, the 2012 did not have the CUE system so I can not speak for that. If the SRX is on your short list - consider a 2012 or 2013 Premium model. You will save a ton of money and get a better warranty. A Cadillac dealer will CPO it which boosts the warranty to 6 yr/100,000 miles rather than the 4yr/50k warranty on a new one. Also, it will still be under the factory 4yr maintenance warranty. Just some ideas - good luck in your shopping.
2 people found this helpful.