04 PT Cruiser possible oil issue after overheating problem

Asked by Ashley Oct 04, 2017 at 01:49 AM about the 2004 Chrysler PT Cruiser Wagon FWD

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

This may be slightly long but, bear with me. I'm not
sure what details about the car's previous state will
help shed light on the answer to my problem so, I'll
start from the beginning.
Bought the car in March with ~170,000 miles. Ran
great. Seemed to have no issues. Within a couple
of months, a.c. started to go out. Eventually, it
wouldn't blow cold or cool air then not long after
that, started overheating when idling sometimes
with or without a.c. on. Then, started overheating
unless it was drove at a high enough speed to cool
it off. Then, would overheat no matter what (even
with heat on full blast, etc.) Thought the problem
was my high relay. Bought a new cooling fan and
same issue so, took it back and got a wiring
harness kit just in case it was a bad connector and
never got around to installing it. No other vehicle
and I'm in school so, continued to drive it while
dealing with it overheating every so often until one
day the check engine oil light came on while it was
overheating and the engine shut itself off. My
Papaw worked on it and said he fixed the fan, a.c.,
and overheating issue. Drove perfect for about 40
miles then same thing happened again. (Should
mention I changed my oil maybe a month before
this.) Decided to look at it myself after he "fixed" it
once more and it again drove fine for 40 miles or
so then engine shut itself off again with the check
engine light on and it overheating. My serpentine
belt was completely off. Apparently, when it was
replaced before my a.c. started going out because
my power steering was out one day, it wasn't put
on properly and had been off for I don't know how
long. Got it put back on and filled my radiator with
water (I had been having problems keeping it filled,
due to overheating I'm sure and didn't want to
water any more money on coolant if it was still
going to do it) and correctly pressurized it with the
valve, which I'm positive no one else had been
doing when they were working on it. Correct me if
I'm wrong, but do you not need to use the valve to
let out excess air in radiator for pressure to be right
or will radiator work out the air on it's own? Either
way, once I did all that, I had no problems driving it
for almost a day. When it finally died, it felt like it
wss accelerating itself a little then it backed off
and sounded like it was going to die then
accelerated again and repeated that process
probably 3 times then turned itself off and started
smoking badly. When I looked underneath it, there
was oil everywhere on the bottom side of the
engine. Sorry, I'm not entirely mechanically inclined
and the diagrams I've found don't seem to match
up to what I was looking at so, I don't know what
parts exactly the oil was on. I checked my oil level
3 or 4 times over the next couple days and it was
the same as before, right below max. Now, it has
been sitting for a week and the oil level is at
minimum and when I try to start it, it's a whining
sound that it makes and it doesn't sound like it's
trying to turn over at all. I took pictures of what I
thought the issue is. There's a part that seems to
not sit correctly on the piece it's connected to. I'm
trying to figure out what that piece is and also if I'm
wasting my time trying to fix it because my engines
blown.
Side note: when I put my serpentine belt on, I
noticed my air filter was filthy so I sprayed it off
and let it dry some and put it back in. I didn't know
you weren't supposed to get them wet. It wasn't
soaking wet but, it was slightly damp still. I'm not
sure if that's relevant to my problem or not.

3 Answers

145

I would consider that cars engine to be toast after everything you said, and you might just want to find another car. The oil pouring out is obviously a blown head, or something to that nature, and you will be spending a heap of money, on what sounds like a pretty messed up car to begin with.

59,825

The air filter is toast now, but I do no think that is all the issue. Sounds like a bad oil leak. Now I am not addressing this from the top issue I read from you but from the bottom of you post up. The repeated over-heating now is and may have been all the time a blown head gasket, with repeated over-heating the head warps and blows the head gasket. The Belt off did not help it, but I doubt it was off the whole time as the alternator would not have been charging the battery and the battery would have lost a charge and not have had the power to crank or drive anymore. The fans not working (or working as I am not sure if you knew it worked or not) may have started this over-heating problem. The oil leak may be a result of gasket failures too due to heat but not real likely, May be oil filter seal leaking, Spose to put oil on it the seal before mounting it. I think the best advise is to do a compression test on all cylinders to confirm if head gasket or piston rings/seals are bad, if so it is not worth the money to fix it. Also head gaskets can still be bad and not show in compression test as the same in the next test which is a test to see if there is exhaust in the cooling system. Sometimes a head gasket failure will allow gases to escape in the cooling system and there is a test to confirm this or not. If the engine fails either of these to test then it is not worth the fix unless you have a perfectly running 04 Pt sitting around that you have no money in the job other than labour. The oil leak needs resolved if planning to fix this which is also possible with new head and new gasket, the old head will continue to warp after re-surfacing so junk it. The real main issue I would have with re-using this engine after the repeated over-heating is that when this happens the interior of the engine gets cooked oil plugging the oil galleries and ruins the bottom end main bearings and scars the cylinder walls and it is then just a matter of time before the bottom end is bad which may already be the case. Sorry but you either have a lot of work to do or pay to have done or you can sell it for parts and start over. I would not buy another Pt cruzer these are known to be pure junk. Maybe buy a Toyota Corrolla or a Camry, or Honda Civic or Accord, as long as they have been kept up used. Also as a side note as you say: All will need maintenance and all you interested in buying need researched for known issues before buying. All engines with timing belts need changed out before they break, and with higher miles, the more will need done sooner. Buy with records of service done and if their is little done then look elsewhere if buying used. Front wheel bearing and C/V axles cost a lot to replace, many sell before they have to service them too.

2 people found this helpful.
Best Answer Mark helpful

Your Answer:

PT Cruiser

Looking for a Used PT Cruiser in your area?

CarGurus has 14 nationwide PT Cruiser listings starting at $4,995.

Postal Code:

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
    Kelly Little Ashford
    Reputation
    4,520
  • #2
    Gypsy Rose
    Reputation
    3,380
  • #3
    docwade931
    Reputation
    2,910
View All

Find great deals from top-rated dealers

Search

Related Models For Sale

Used Chrysler Sebring
3 Great Deals out of 33 listings starting at $4,531
Used Pontiac Vibe
28 listings starting at $4,800

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.