Engine light problem on 2005 Toyota Corolla

30

Asked by pmpat Mar 02, 2015 at 02:42 PM about the 2005 Toyota Corolla LE

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

I', having a problem with my engine light, which first came on over a year ago in Jan. 2014. I  took the car to my mechanic, who I trust and who has been servicing the car since I bought it.. The diagnostic code that came up was P0171. He said that there were a few things that could be causing the light to come on. But he thought the first thing to do was to replace the front air fuel ratio sensor which cost $280 for parts and labor .So I had it replaced.  I should mention that I always put the air cap on tightly, because that can cause the light to come on also. Then, last November, the light came on again and he put some fuel cleaner in the gas tank. It came on again this past Jan. 2015. He then replaced the mass air flow sensor for $191, parts and labor. Now, a month later,  it has come on again. I am so disgusted but I don't know what to do.. The light doesn't blink and it's always the same code that shows up. I know it's not dangerous to have the light on but I know I won't be able to get the car inspected, which is due in July. Any advice anyone? I can't afford to keep putting in new sensors!!  Also, do you think my mechanic is bilking me? Is there any way to get a better, more accurate reading on the problem? The car only has 70,000  miles.

17 Answers

P0171 is lean condition. Maybe unmetered air getting in to intake, from a vacuum leak, a faulty MAF, and possibly a weak fuel pump not supplying enough fuel. If he can't diagnose it, which is even harder for me from behind a keyboard, (at the risk of flattering myself I know Corollas and the 1.8 1ZZ FE better than I know any other car. I have one) you need to take it to a Dealer. Have it fixed properly once and for all. Have a look here also: http://www.samarins.com/diagnose/p0171.html

10 people found this helpful.

By the way, there is no such thing as a "front Air Fuel Ratio sensor" the fuel trim is determined by the ECU using signals from the MAF.-- MAP.-- o2 sensors-- all in concert. A vacuum leak from a large source such as PCV throws everything off. Even a bad camshaft position sensor can enter the picture, but this is unlikely. But that would effect the timing and amount of injectors. Your car has coil on plug ignition, and timing is crucial. I am fully aware of cost of dealer service but they have diagnostic computers most shops can only dream of owning

3 people found this helpful.
30

Thanks very much. I hesitated going to the dealer because they can be so costly but I guess I have no choice. I hope I don't get a runaround from them too. Maybe they have a better code machine?

3 people found this helpful.

Much better. That's what I meant by they have diagnostic computers most shops can only dream of owning. Toyota -specific diagnostic computers that run upwards of $15,000. A do-all shop, even competent, honest mechanics can't afford Toyota-specific ones.

6 people found this helpful.

One more thing if I may: Important to buy Brand-name gas. Gas at convenience stores and independent retailers even Pilot, Loves's, are made by small refineries that do not have detergents and other additives that (not limited to but include) Shell, Chevron, Exxon/Mobil, 76, those big names. Cheap gas is, well, cheap gas

6 people found this helpful.
65

Time to take your vehicle to an ASE certified technician that won't start firing parts at the car immediately after gathering the vehicle's DTC's. Find a technician not a mechanic. As an automotive service professional, the word "mechanic" makes me cringe. I'm an educated, well versed "technician". To me a "mechanic" repairs mechanical components. A technician is an educated professional who understands and executes the 6 step diagnostic and repair procedure. Nowhere in that procedure does it ever recommend replacing a random part in hopes the vehicle becomes fixed. Backyard mechanics are the ones who follow the "Well, lets just replace some parts and hope it starts" mantra. Diagnosis is what separates the men from the boys. Anybody can learn how to change an old part with a new part. That's caveman stuff. Knowing a system's functional operation is half of the battle. If you do not study or research function & operation of a vehicle's system prior to attempting diagnosis, you'll always be guessing. How can you understand what's actually wrong if you aren't 100% sure how that system works? I spend most of my day reading and comprehending service information after verifying the customer's concern. If I cannot duplicate the concern and there are no DTC's, why continue chasing a ghost? If I do verify, depending on the concern, I'll most likely plug in the OEM scan tool and print any and all DTC's. At that point the research begins if I'm not 100% familiar with the certain vehicle or system. Your mechanic is what we call a "hack" or shade tree, hillbilly mechanic. Probably uses lots of zip ties and either duct tape or electrical tape. Most likely doesn't own or know ow to use a Digital Multi Meter

6 people found this helpful.
60

My 2005 Corolla has the "check engine" symbol on again! It's been coming on and off for the past 14,000 miles. I've had 3 different mechanics, including the dealer, do a diagnostic which mentions the transmission. However, it's a little vague as to what part of the transmission. And in 14,000 I haven't felt anything wrong with the car! I had accidentally run up over a curb onto a little island, and then had to drive off of it. It was on the way home from that incident that it first happened. I had good mechanics look under the car when it was on a lift and they checked over the car and found nothing. It was off for a while now, and after a long 70 mile trip, came on again. I don't feel safe going far in the car and I'm afraid to buy another new Toyota and get the same problem.

1 people found this helpful.
60

GuruZQS12 CORRECTION!!!!! I have a 2006 Toyota Corolla, NOT a 2005 as I stated above. And, lo and behold, the CHECK ENGINE LIGHT went off again after about a week and I did NOTHING for that to have happened. Who can figure?

3 people found this helpful.
160

I have a 2005 Corolla and long, long story short, I firmly believe the "Check Engine Light" and code system is faulty! Light has been on and off for about 4 years now. When it comes time for a smog check, I have to catch it during one of the OFF periods. Have learned that if the "Light" is the only symptom, ignore the light.

10 people found this helpful.
30

I a 82 and living on social security. I can't afford a new car if something is major, and I love my 2005 corolla. I am paranoid about my car breaking down on me be on repair. What do you think?

3 people found this helpful.
160

Same as 528MQ, I also firmly believe the Check Engine Light System is faulty. First time mine came on dealer told me "code" indicated I needed transmission work to the tune of $3800. As the light was the ONLY symptom of any problem, I declined. 5 years later I've still not needed to do any transmission work. Now I just ignore it and catch it in one of it's OFF times when I need to smog.

6 people found this helpful.
60

My 2006 Corolla's "Check Engine Light" is still going on and off for about 30,000 miles without feeling anything wrong with my car. It usually comes on after a long trip, but on the way home. Lately, it seems to go off after a shorter amount of time, such as the next day. I've been to Toyota, and they wanted $3,500. to fix some type of transmission problem. I've had 2 other diagnostics that say the same thing, but I feel nothing wrong with the transmission. One of the mechanic's diagnostic said that something got stuck, and that mechanic seemed to think it was nothing to worry about. I don't feel safe in my car if I go a long distance since I always wonder if this is the time my car will break down. I still don't feel anything wrong. When I need to inspect the car, I wait until the light goes off again.

2 people found this helpful.
10

I have the same concerns about my 2005 corolla, since I bougth that in 2010 the light come on and off, but since the Toyota changed my airbag passenger the light not go way. I bougth a new car but I need to fix this problem for do the the car inspected, which is due last January. I don't know what to do, some suggest?

1 people found this helpful.
60

If you unplug your battery cable and reinstall it on your 2005 Toyota, the check light will go off for a good month or two. At least you can get through inspection. But maybe not due to I have noticed when I reset the check switch it has a fuel smell like maybe carbon monoxide leak. I believe there maybe be a fuel sensor or a bad catalytic converter. But not sure. Toyota factory rep should be able to diagnose this problem.

4 people found this helpful.
60

I don't believe in those code info from parts houses like Auto Zone, Standard Parts. or Orielly You might waste a lot of money and still have problems. I went to three different auto parts places and got 3 different answers on my problem with the check engine light coming on. If a factory rep trouble shoots your car he should catch that problem .

2 people found this helpful.
10

I did the diagnostics on my daughters 2005 Corolla and it had multiple codes showing, looked up the toyota service bulletin from Jan 30 2006 and the five codes matched with an issue with the charcoal evap unit under the rear axle area. PO43E, PO43F, P2401, P2402, P2419. Ordered parts and cleared the codes but until its replaced the ck engine light will come back on.....

1 people found this helpful.

Your Answer:

Corolla

Looking for a Used Corolla in your area?

CarGurus has 2,438 nationwide Corolla listings starting at $4,295.

Postal Code:

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
    Jeff Polhemus
    Reputation
    3,440
  • #2
    Gene Arnett
    Reputation
    3,280
  • #3
    hashimmir
    Reputation
    2,520
View All

Find great deals from top-rated dealers

Search

Related Models For Sale

Used Toyota Camry
60 Great Deals out of 1,072 listings starting at $3,995
Used Honda Civic
195 Great Deals out of 4,054 listings starting at $440
Used Honda Accord
55 Great Deals out of 995 listings starting at $2,000
Used Toyota RAV4
100 Great Deals out of 2,715 listings starting at $2,500
Used Toyota Tacoma
46 Great Deals out of 1,074 listings starting at $9,995
Used Toyota Prius
10 Great Deals out of 165 listings starting at $4,988
Used Honda CR-V
88 Great Deals out of 4,524 listings starting at $440
Used Mazda MAZDA3
67 Great Deals out of 1,632 listings starting at $1,899
Used Hyundai Elantra
156 Great Deals out of 4,214 listings starting at $100
Used Toyota Highlander
26 Great Deals out of 777 listings starting at $6,500
Used Toyota 4Runner
19 Great Deals out of 300 listings starting at $10,800
Used Nissan Sentra
65 Great Deals out of 1,744 listings starting at $1,995

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.